|
The QBC Test, developed by Becton and Dickenson Inc.,
(now marketed by
QBC Diagnostics,
Inc.) is a new
method for identifying the malarial parasite in the peripheral blood. It involves staining
of the centrifuged and compressed red cell layer with acridine orange and its examination
under UV light source. It is fast, easy and claimed to be more sensitive than the
traditional thick smear examination.
Method: The QBC tube is a high-precision glass hematocrit
tube, pre-coated internally with acridine orange stain and potassium oxalate. It is filled
with 55-65 microliters of blood from a finger, ear or heel puncture. A clear plastic
closure is then attached. A precisely made cylindrical float, designed to be suspended in
the packed red blood cells, is inserted. The tube is centrifuged at 12,000 rpm for 5
minutes. The components of the buffy coat separate according to their densities, forming
discrete bands. Because the float occupies 90% of the internal lumen of the tube, the
leukocyte and the thrombocyte cell band widths and the top-most area of red cells are
enlarged to 10 times normal. The QBC tube is placed on the tube holder and examined using
a standard white light microscope equipped with the UV microscope adapter, an
epi-illuminated microscope objective. Fluorescing parasites are then observed at the red
blood cell/white blood cell interface.
The key feature of the
method is centrifugation and thereby concentration of the red blood cells in a predictable
area of the QBC tube, making detection easy and fast. Red cells containing Plasmodia are
less dense than normal ones and concentrate just below the leukocytes, at the top of the
erythrocyte column. The float forces all the surrounding red cells into the 40 micron space
between its outside circumference and the inside of the tube. Since the parasites contain
DNA which takes up the acridine orange stain, they appear as bright specks of light among
the non-fluorescing red cells. Virtually all of the parasites found in the 60 microliter
of blood can be visualized by rotating the tube under the microscope. A negative test can
be reported within one minute and positive result within minutes.
Comparison
between peripheral smear and QBC test for detecting malaria
| |
Peripheral smear |
QBC |
| Method |
Cumbersome |
Easy |
| Time |
Longer, 60 - 120 minutes |
Faster, 15 - 30 minutes |
| Sensitivity |
5 parasites/µl in thick film and 200 / µl in thin film |
Claimed to be more sensitive, at least as good as a thick film |
| Specificity |
Gold standard |
? False positives, artifacts may be reported as positive by
not-so-well-trained technicians |
| Species identification |
Accurate, gold standard |
Difficult to impossible |
| Cost |
Inexpensive |
Costly equipment and consumables |
| Acceptability |
100% |
Not so |
| Availability |
Everywhere |
Limited |
| Other |
-- |
Accidentally can detect filarial worms |
|
|
Comparative
Analysis of QBC and Thick Film Microscopy:
Study done at Kasturba Medical College Diagnostic Centre, Mangalore (Urmila Shenoi et al)
Total number of samples examined |
18,845 |
Total number positive by QBC |
4,824 |
Total number positive by thick film |
3,490 |
Positivity rate of QBC |
25% |
Positivity rate of thick film |
18 % |
Therefore, whenever in
doubt, ask for a peripheral smear study, particularly for species identification. There
are instances of cases diagnosed as vivax malaria on the QBC, but soon after developed
fatal complications of falciparum malaria.
A 65 year old man came to
the hospital at 8 P.M. with history of fever and chills of one day's duration. His QBC
test was reported positive for many trophozoites of P. vivax. He was started on
chloroquine and primaquine. Next morning at 9.30 A.M. he developed generalised tonic
clonic convulsions and lost consciousness. He was immediately brought to the hospital and
found to be in deep unarousable coma. His peripheral smear examination showed P.
falciparum and the parasite count was 35%. He was started on Inj. Quinine, but he died
after 3 days.
Other Tests:
1. Peripheral Smear
2. Para Sight F test
3. OptiMal Assay
4. The immuno chromatographic test (ICT Malaria P. f. test)
5. Polymerase Chain Reaction
6. Detection of antibodies by Radio immuno assay,
immunofluorescence or enzyme immuno assay
|